Matt wasn't sure how
he should feel as he entered the old building that housed the physics
department. A poster on the wall caught his eye and made him chuckle.
The theater department was putting on an adaptation of Charles
Dickens' “Tale of Two Cities”.
“It
was the best of times, it was the worst of times,” Matt nodded
appreciably. “That about sums it up.”
Everything in the
building, walls, floors, ceiling, was white and the intense lights
reflected off of everything, dazzling his eyes. Memories of the
headaches he use to get in this building came back to him and he
wondered at how he'd never figured out why. Matt ignored the elevator
and instead took the stairs. The stairwell, while intended only for
emergencies, was not alarmed and the dull concrete grays were a
welcomed relief to his already throbbing eyes.
Matt checked the
scribbled note on the back of his hand. Dr. Muto had moved offices
since the last time they'd seen each other. When he and Matt first
met, Dr. Muto's office was in the basement in a back corner. They use
to joke that the office was so small that it must have been a janitor
closet before. The joke lost its appeal when, after an experiment
ruined the carpet, they found the floor drain. Shortly after that day
was when Dr. Muto moved offices for the first time. Then again, and
again, each time to a slightly nicer, slightly bigger office, and
always on a floor higher. Matt paused on the fifth floor landing,
briefly regretting his decision to take the stairs, and checked the
note on his hand again. Dr. Muto's office was one more floor up, just
shy of the Dean's Complex on the seventh floor. Matt climbed the last
few steps to the sixth floor and gave himself a minute to catch his
breath.
“I
need to get out more,” He said, wiping his forehead on his sleeve.
At last he was ready
and pushed open the door. The bright whiteness immediately assaulted
his eyes and he had to blink several times before his eyes could
adjust. To his side, the elevator dinged and its doors opened. Judge
Dervin stepped out. It was odd to see Judge Dervin out of his robes
and instead in regular clothes. For a moment they both stared at one
another
“Hi,”
Matt said at last, waving an awkward hand.
Judge Dervin glanced
over to the door Matt had just come through. “You took the stairs?”
He asked.
Matt nodded.
“Wish
I had your energy,” Judge Dervin sighed.
“Me
too,” Matt said.
Judge Dervin looked
at him, puzzled. “What?” He asked.
“I
wish I had my energy too,” Matt said. “I seem to have lost it all
in the stairwell.”
Judge Dervin
chortled and patted Matt on the shoulder. Matt didn't know what to
make of it. Since they'd never really been on good terms with one
another, such an obviously friendly gesture was a bit of a shock.
“Glad
you could make it,” Judge Dervin said and then turned to lead the
way to Dr. Muto's office.
“Thanks
for the invite,” Matt said with not quite enough conviction in his
voice.
Judge Dervin eyed
him as they walked along. “I did get him to agree to meeting us
here like you asked, instead of the courthouse.”
“Yes,
thank you for that.”
“I
thought you'd be a bit happier to be back here,” Judge Dervin said.
“Why?”
Matt asked, “You know they kicked me out.”
“Well,”
Judge Dervin fished around, “You just sounded so eager on the phone
to have the meeting here.”
Matt chuckled and
shook his head. He'd been eager to not meet in the courthouse. Just
being in the building made him uncomfortable, feel like he was
trapped, imprisoned. Here at least he could walk out at any time
without fear of being restrained.
Judge Dervin looked
like he was about to speak and so Matt, noticing that they'd reached
Dr. Muto's office, knocked on the door and put an end to his and
Judge Dervin's conversation.
A moment later, the
door swung open and Dr. Muto waved them silently into his office.
There were cups of tea for them all, placed perfectly on the table in
the center of the room. Three chairs were placed around the table.
Dr. Muto's desk was off to the side, clean and organized. Matt
frowned. He missed the Dr. Muto who's office was nothing more than a
glorified broom cupboard. The happy, excited genius who would help
students on their unapproved projects simply because he thought they
were interesting. Certainly Dr. Muto had always had his quirks, his
knack for cleanliness and perfection, but back then those things had
been endearing. Now they were imposing.
“Thank
you for letting us meet here,” Judge Dervin said when they'd all
taken their seats.
Dr. Muto waved a
dismissive hand. “It made sense,” He said curtly. “The
university is a central location where the courthouse is not.”
Dr. Muto took a sip
of his tea. Matt did as well, remembering back to the times they'd
taken turns brewing it while the other kept working on whatever
project they had at hand. Judge Dervin tested the tea, downing a
polite sip before placing the cup back down on the table.
“Now,
what can I do for you?” Dr. Muto asked, turning to Judge Dervin.
Judge Dervin pulled
out a folder and opened it, revealing copious notes. “You expelled
this young man, after the two of you fought,” Judge Dervin began,
“after he presented a thesis that you have admitted to be correct.
Why?”
Matt almost spit out
his tea. For a moment he considered standing up and leaving but his
body didn't respond to any of his commands to rise and so he decided
to sit it out and watch.
Dr. Muto shot a
glance at Matt, but Matt was fairly certain his own expression of
shock and horror would be enough to convince Dr. Muto that Judge
Dervin was acting of his own accord.
“I
see,” Dr. Muto said, placing his cup back down on the table.
Matt couldn't help
but notice how Dr. Muto placed his cup in such a way that it formed a
perfect isosceles triangle with the other two cups.
“I
told you before,” Dr. Muto said, “Matt's ideas were not new and
our disagreements came on the implementation.”
“And
what does that mean?” Judge Dervin demanded.
Matt, again, felt
like leaving but couldn't.
“It
means his thesis was political statement, a social-economic piece of
wishful thinking.”
Matt dug his fingers
down into his chair, blood pumping in his head as the anger rushed
back in on him. Anger he thought he'd let go of.
“At
least,” Dr. Muto said, his voice softening, “That was what I
thought then, and I was wrong.”
Matt blinked. Dr.
Muto, sitting there in front of him, was looking at him in the same
way he use to all those years ago in his basement office. Like a
proud parent.
“I
have never felt right about how those events played out,” Dr. Muto
said, now speaking directly to Matt, “I've read and reread the
thesis since then and, after my conversation with Judge Dervin, I
finally began to understand.”
Dr. Muto got up from
the table and moved over to his desk. He picked up a thin stack of
papers and returned to the table. He thumbed through them, as though
making sure everything was in order and then handed them over to
Matt.
“I've
spoken to the Dean,” Dr. Muto went on as Matt scanned the papers,
not believing his eyes, “And with the President of the university.
They've both agreed, as you can see there, to revoke your previous
expulsion, grant you your doctorate and,” Dr. Muto paused to take a
sip of tea at the same time that Matt reached the final sheet of
paper.
In moments he'd read
through it. Dr. Muto let him read through it again.
“And,”
Dr. Muto said when Matt looked up from the paper, “Grant you space
here to work on developing your ideas.”
“It
says here I'd be made an assistant professor,” Matt said,
dumbfounded.
Judge Dervin took
the papers from Matt's shaking hands and looked through them.
“Yes,”
Dr. Muto said. “We are all aware of how hard we made things for you
over these past few years and feel it only fair to try to make things
up to you.”
Matt still couldn't
believe it. He glanced over to Judge Dervin who was frowning.
“And
what does he have to do in return?” Judge Dervin asked, setting the
papers down.
“What
do you mean?” Dr. Muto asked.
“Does
Matt have to sign some kind of paper absolving the university of any
wrong doing for the expulsion?”
“Why
would we have him sign anything like that?” Dr. Muto asked, “We
are apologizing, not bribing.”
Judge Dervin huffed
at that but said nothing else.
“Really,
Matt,” Dr. Muto said, “You don't have to do anything you don't
want to. We really are sorry. We were wrong and we are taking
responsibility for our mistakes.”
Matt was about to
reply when Judge Dervin's cell phone rang.
“I'm
sorry,” He said, and answered the phone. “Judge Dervin speaking.”
Dr. Muto's smile
faded slightly but he otherwise sat patiently. Matt continued to sit
and stare at the papers before him. Everything he'd ever wanted.
Funding for his projects. Never having to write another stupid paper
for the Bleeding Edge.
“...where
was it?” Judge Dervin was saying as he scribbled down some notes in
his folder. “Yes, certainly, I'll call the airline and...oh, I
see...alright then, I'll call you tonight when I get in. Bye.”
Judge Dervin hung up. “I'm sorry but I must be going,” He said,
rising from the table and collecting his things.
“Is
something the matter?” Dr. Muto asked.
“My
daughter went missing a few days back,” Judge Dervin said, “They
just found her car and they're flying me out tonight.” With that,
Judge Dervin turned and left the room.
“Poor
man,” Dr. Muto said.
“Yeah,
but at least he gets to go someplace warm,” Matt said.
“Hmm?”
“Oh,
the address he wrote down was in Texas,”
Dr. Muto's smile
slipped even further. “Where exactly?” He asked.
Matt shut his eyes,
envisioning in his mind what he'd seen and then tracing in out with
his finger on the table. Dr. Muto jumped up from his seat and rushed
to the phone.
“Thank
you,” He said hurriedly, “But I just remembered I was suppose to
call someone. Please take those papers with you, think it over and
let me know when you've come to a decision.”
Matt stumbled out of
the room and back into the blinding white light, utterly confused but
pleased with the results of the meeting.